Thank you so much for the comment Ladies

Gonnabeme thank you so much for the link but because of my poor network i can't upload it, i'll let you in my tot after readin it.

Mafalda:

Lets analyze your consern:

1.) You said that JS had a gf and broke-off durin YB season because of the ff proff: constant txting and calling while filming, mama Jang seing a fortune teller, etc.
2.) You said that the rin might be a complement.
3.) YOu said why would JS flirt with SH when he has a gf?

Questions and comments:

1.) First of all JS is a private person, he will tell anythin and everything about himself and his past relationship but never the present. This was proven during the radio station booth where Hungchun talking to Hongwa, and when HOngwa was about to say something regarding JS he cut him off and change the topic. Secondly, JS is honest and straight person, again this was proven during the Champagne show where he have to answer difficult questions in front of all his leading ladies no matter how embarrasing he is. So JS being honest and straightforward person will not lie about his GF but would keep it private as possible.
Regarding him txting and calling while filming, it does'nt mean that his talkin to his GF, it might be his friend, Henchun for instant. He's a friendly guy, he have lots of "idol" girl friend maybe thats why SH is a little bit jealous about that.

And honestly i don't think mama Jang is involve here. From the way QB discuss it, mama Jang, being a mom always have the last thing to say, which makes her pretty confident of his son. The fact that she consulted a "fortune teller" doesn't mean she's worried of JS "apparent GF" She wasn't concern before and not today. She knows her decision counts a lot.

2.) the famous "ring" this has been discussed here many times, if you think that ring was given by his GF that has yet to be proven. But because of its similarity to SH ring and HOngkee acknowledging it durin the SBS award by teasing him of wearin the same ring as his and them wearing the same ring on SBS award and wearin it in other circumstances led us to believed that its a couple ring. But in the end it was never really proven.

3.) Precisely why would JS "flirt" with SH when he knows he had a GF? more so why would SH behave that way when she knows JS Oppa had a GF? SH would definietely behave if she knows JS have GF same way with JS just like what you said, in respect for his GF. Another thing SH said in the MOok interview that theres no secret between them and JS said theres on bounderies between them having said that you can draw your own conclusion.;


Lastly, the Korean staff of YB who said JS had GF and broke off during YB how reliable is he/ she? How accurate? Does she/he by any chance close to JS? Close enough to confess about he's GF? Close enough than SH and HOngke? In the anything rumoured unless proven remains to be a romoured.

Thanks.

Next to comment is piggymorry, but i have to hold it for now, coz' my class will start now.

Godbless to all of you!!!

2.) The famous "ring" it has been discuss here many times

Edit:
OOPs sorry it should be HOngke not Hongwa. (mistake)

(Hi July, I merged this second short post with this one)

just to add on.. did a quick search.. this quote is in about 2 or 3 posts over the net.

the official word as below.

“We do not know where Jang Geun-Suk was staying at last year’s Christmas Eve. Regarding the ring, he has many accessories. He doesn’t have a girlfriend currently.”

this in reply to the question of him attending some magic concert with 3 other people. one of which was a lady whom was rumored to be spotted wearing the same ring as him thus labeled as his girl. his appearance was rumored anyway...

Thanks for your comments July! You're always so kind!! Now I have everything clear!

I was very confused because if JGS really had a girlfriend, there were a lot of contradictories with respect to our theories 8790.

Furthermore, reading the second part of the interview, I'm sure the reporter noticed something between them, very clever, because he asked JGS how he felt seeing her with wedding dress ...

I sincerely believe that at this time that they have been separated, as in the drama, they have realized that they can't be without each other and like each other (JGS worried about her health, asking her manager, he say that she's really beautiful ...)

@Biane Ong
Thank you so much Biane Ong for doing that. Apreciate it!!

@ Allygirl

Thank you so much for the article. From the moment there i thought you wrote it all.

@Gonnabeme
I've read it already, i love it. It only shows how very attractive our dear princess is. I wonder how JS takes it? So this interview is way before JS "Champagne"? hhmmmm.............................. (thinking)

@Mafalda

Your most welcome. Hope you understand even with typo error my "g" keys are not workin properly. Lets analyze together next time it would be fun!!

@greybunny

some of your comments makes me wonder if you have read some of the preview comments made by the people here in 8790. You might have a different perspective once you read all the girls' comment and will help you understand why we look at it differently from your point of view. Actually, these girls already discussed, dissected, observed, reasearched etc. everything conserning JS and SH as well as the other 2 ANJell. It wouldn't have reach this far if the topic were not interesting.

Anyway, i find your comment with Allygirl kinda rude, you may address her with her name and choose a better word so as not to be misinterpreded as being arogant. (sorry 'bout that.) but this is the only way i know how we can show our respect to everyone since we're not seeing face to face.

Your comments are welcome but i suggest you put some facts to make it more congreet like the ff.:

1.) You said that in the bts they are fooling around and playing than flirting. But you think its a result of having to be in each others company for 24/7 x 60 day and that the group became so close its possible the usual gender properties got blurred.

2.) You said that KS has a tease devil in him, he fouund out about SH behind the ear sensitiveness and likes to tease her. They know there are cameras on them and there are people eyes on them.

3.) You said as much as we fans want to spazz, i think that they have the good sense not to behave out of bounds in front of the whole crew.

* from these 3 comments your point exactly is that JS doesn't see SH as anything rather than co-actor? is that it?

SUGGESTION:

1.) Straigthen your facts so we can discuss this.
2.) Try reading 8790 thread you may get your answers along the way.
3.) Make your point clear.


There i said it all Ladies, YOU MAY LOVE ME OR HATE ME, it's up to you. But one thing will never change, i'll stick to this community like a sticky note just to show my support for SH plus the fact that i love the people here. I don't have anything personal what-so-ever with anyone its just an observation and sorry if i can't keep my mouth shout. (pretending like Hongke, slapping left and right cheek).

Thank you.

@ July

No offense taken and I hope my reply here will not offend anyone as well.
But just like to give some explanation on my words

Firstly, if I offended allygirl with the way I refer to her post, I sincerely apologize.
It was a simple question but the style of writing is a habit from chinese forums where post number are refer to so as to be specific. When I posted the comment, in the event that someone posted before me, it would be easier to refer to the post number.

I shall take care not to use this method of referencing from now on since I seemed to be weaving between both writing styles. (I think I did it on another post...)

In regards to previous pages of this topic,

I've been following this thread from page 1. all 100+ pages of it. Perhaps I am a new boarder.. but I did read everything and considered all the points previously discussed. I read the thread for a couple of days since I signed up and had enjoyed all the posts thoroughly. Especially the mimic theory which I believe is a very intellectual and an interesting point of view. It is also because of this thread that I decided to participate in the forum instead of lurking, seeing how fun and friendly everyone was.

I like this couple very much and feel that they have something more. But to be more substantial, I give doubts and discount those areas which I feel may be resultant of other factors/possibilities. Of course, not everyone may agree with me and thus we can have friendly discussions like right now ^ ^.

IMHO, there are many interesting behaviors between these two people which is why I like this thread so much as many people on board would come up with their own take of what may be happening.

About my points. Again, I stress that not everyone may accept this.. but it is my take/interpretation
Also, the comments were actually in reply/response to the previous post by mafalda who was confused about SH and KS behavior.

1) I cannot discount the fact that in an environment when people are together 24/7 x60days, behavior patterns may converge. When I watched and rewatched their BTS, I listened to their speech patterns and considered how much is flirting and how much is playing. As this point cannot be concrete, I take the side of the doubt and choose to see them as playing.

2) Then there is the fact that there are cameras around them. Throw in the culture aspect... wouldn't it be improper? so I wondered again...

But the concluding point was, although there are cameras and crew, ... KS seemed to enjoy teasing SH very much. To be more accurate, it seems he cannot help himself but tease her... (the ear thing.. it appeared a couple of times. Him making comments that makes SH embarrassed eg. during samsung event.. ) so I wrote "there's some truth in the "boys always like to prank on girls they fancy" saying" ...

This is a point that made me feel that KS has something for SH despite point 1 and 2 above. (although the strongest point to me was him saying his mom likes SH... this was in another post I wrote to agree with another writer.)

3) I apologize, this point is probably vague. I meant to say I believe they are mature young adults thus the comment that they have good sense not to behave out of bounds in front of the whole crew... Be it whether KS had a gf or not during that time, I do not think SH and KS went overboard with each other. I think their bed scene was really cute but nothing too improper... This is what I felt in response to mafalda's post.

Sorry if I sounded contradictory... I'll blame it on my habit of self-debate... In self-debating, I can cancel points which I find may swing either way... and in doing so, I look for stronger points that has nothing or little to contradict it.

Hopefully this clears things up ^ ^;;
Otherwise... Otokajo ? >_<

I am raving at your analysis Rin/GB!

I like how you take me back to my own process of self doubt when analyzing this couple we love so much. I like that you're trying so cautiously, and so hard to be objective.

I do hope that the saying a guy in love likes to tease the girl they like is true (couldn't quote your exact words as I'm typing from my mobile). (all: pardon typos and incomplete thoughts as I am responding from my mobile, will edit later. )

In the end, we will agree on one thing. Around each other, 8790 are comfortable enough to show their true selves but within bounds of culture and self-respect.

Even if he had a gf at the time, I think a guy can still tease a girl he likes, not to possess her or anything but simply to make her feel good or for fun. Similar to it being okay having a huge crush with someone even if you're in a serious relationship. If he can be honest with the girl to make her understand his committed situation, then a good girl should know not to read too much to his teasing and guard her own reactions, which I think is what Shin Hye did. There was no malice in how she responds to JGS, so clearly she knew her place with him.

The relationship JGS had did fall apart at one point between filming and the holiday. I don't think SH is the reason but could be JGS realizing that he can't keep up with his own conflicting emotions between loyalty and novelty. With a girl like SH, I can imagine it's hard for a guy not to fall.

I think the cooling-off between the two has something related with JGS' breakup as seeing him not committed created clouds of confusion in SH's mind. How does she react now that he is free? Do his actions mean more than she thinks they mean? I don't think she wanted to be the rebound girl.

The fact that JGS stuck around, is close to her manager, and tried to keep communication lines open are evidence enough that he cares for her and would probably like to pursue her in the proper and certain way. I think JGS is just in the process of sorting his feelings out as this is fairly new to him. PSH does not fit into his "type" but the emotions he feels are not something he could just ignore.

K, sorry for interrupting girls. ^^

I really don't know what's going on, and I would also like to say sorry because I was busy with my college admission. I was forced not to lurk around.

Anyway, let's all cool down girls.
Though I know we're all calm persons. Keke~

@ July : Hello! I was not able to ask.. On what will you comment on my reply? I was curious.

After read your comment earthprincess & greybunny , i think maybe both of you are right. KS love to teasing SH...kept teasing until SH respond...and what did he do next?...he became a decent man...both of them step back their position, you can see it in their BST (focus SH 's dress BTS) , I belive SH surely know where she is with him....Ayo...I love them so much especially SH..so I want to see them wil be a real couple in future...althought their "relationship is as good as that a pair of sibling" (Mook 21 mag) noe ...hope someday they say we will married like Jang Dong Gun & Go so Young..

Hey Girls...cheers... =)))
GB..i like how you take this very calm and wise..=>..and yes there's alot of head here..we can't make one agree in one opinion rite..?every view enrich us..in cute way,in scientific way..research to social psichology behavior..i love every words and how everyone analyze and had their own opinion...hey hey hey one thing for sure we love and adore Shin Hye so much.,that's why we always include our emotionally feelings in our analyze...so gilrs calm down..take a deep breath and smile...love you all *wave2*
so in my take..maybe during the YB filming Sukkie had gf..i think his so loyal..but we cant controle our heart rite..this heart things even our brain cant control it..i think from the mook magz interview i can clear up everything..there's something between them..the photos talk to me so much ^^

for the record, i don't think Rin/GB and I are feuding... I love her analyses too!! just wanted to clear that up. we're on the same side basically.